Transparently sell your Toys, Video Games, Cards & Collectibles!
We primarily pay with Venmo or a Business Check Friday's, Saturday or by Appointment with Sean. Store Credit is available everyday.
Video Games |
Video Game Trade-In Values We base our offers on market demand, condition, and completeness, with the strongest payouts going to in-demand titles and complete-in-box games. Most video games typically fall in the range of:
Higher-demand titles — such as Mario, Zelda, Pokémon, Metroid, Resident Evil and other sought-after games — often receive offers in the 60% cash / 70% store credit range, especially on platforms like Nintendo Switch, GameCube, DS/3DS, N64 and SNES. Lower-demand titles, including common games, sports titles, or yearly releases, may receive lower offers based on current demand and resale value. Large collections are evaluated as a whole, and pricing may vary depending on the overall mix of titles and condition. Note: We always aim to offer fair, competitive pricing based on real-time market data, and store credit consistently pays more than cash. |
Pokemon & |
We pay 50% cash or 60% store credit for
Pokémon singles. We pay 70% cash for sealed Magic and Pokemon product of the current market price. We are currently only paying 60% store credit for Magic The Gathering Singles. Yu Gi Oh, Magic and Pokémon bulk are accepted. Around $6.00 per 1000 near-mint cards. No energy. We pay 5 cents per pokemon holographic card. Roughly $5 per 100 cash. We do not buy One Piece singles, Yu Gi Oh singles or Sports Cards. |
Action Figures |
Action Figure Trade-In Values We pay strong offers for SEALED action figures from popular collector lines including Star Wars Black Series, G.I. Joe, Transformers, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Wrestling, He-Man, McFarlane Toys, M.A.S.K., and Thundercats.
Figures that are rare, vintage, or highly collectible may receive higher offers based on condition and demand. LOOSE action figures are generally less desirable but we still purchase them when complete and in good condition.
Note: Figures missing accessories, weapons, or packaging may receive lower offers. High-demand characters and vintage toys tend to receive the strongest payouts. |
Graphic Novels, Manga Books |
Because we sell graphic novels and manga at 50% off MSRP every day, we pay 20% cash or 25% store credit of MSRP for items in very good condition. |
Dungeons & Dragons manuals, Warhammer, Pathfinder |
We pay 40% cash or 50% store credit for Dungeons & Dragons and Warhammer books, accessories, dice, and more, based on sales history and condition. |
LEGO Bulk, Minifigs and New LEGO Sets |
We buy tubs of bulk LEGO brick, LEGO minifigures, and new LEGO sets. We do not buy used, pre-built LEGO.
Pre-Built/Used LEGO or High Priced Minifigs? |
Loose Wrestling Figures, Amiibo's, Skylanders, Disney Infinity |
|
Movies, Seasons/Shows, CD's |
|
NECA / Wall Props, Ghostbusters |
We pay 50% cash or 60% store credit for SEALED/CIB NECA, Hot Toys, plastic sword replicas, Sideshow Collectibles, and other limited edition items, based on condition and demand. |
Hot Wheels ( Pausing as of 8/1/26 ) |
We buy sealed Hot Wheels collections. What we pay ranges from $.50 cents on generic hot wheels up to $2 dollars per Sealed Hot Wheel or Die Cast car. Store credit always gets you more as well. |
Funko Pops ( Pausing as of 8/1/26 ) |
|
We do not currently purchase: |
Pre-80's toys. Antique toys. Trains. Beanie Babies, Barbie dolls, comic books (only graphic novels), sports cards, Yu-Gi-Oh, Lorcana. . |
Cash Payouts: Fridays & Saturdays — No Appointment Needed
Store Credit Trades: Anytime We're Open
Our pricing is transparent and market-based. We reference eBay Sold listings for collectibles, PriceCharting.com for video games, and TCGplayer.com for Pokémon and Magic cards.
We typically pay via Venmo instant cash or store credit (credit pays more). We can also issue a business check if needed. Saturdays around 1pm can be busy, so there may be a short wait. Trades after 5pm are strongly discouraged. Please call if you can only come in after 5pm to trade. We do not accept trades right before closing.
Want an estimate first? Email us at info@cowabungacollectibles.com or message us on Instagram or Facebook. Final offers are confirmed after in-person inspection.
Sean handles most cash trades and card appraisals and is typically in-store Fridays and Saturdays.
We’re located across from Newbury Comics. A cart is available if you’re bringing in multiple items.